Disobeying Islamic Law and Repentance

Question

What is the ruling on individuals who violate Islamic law by undergoing surgical procedures such as liposuction without first considering whether the doctor is male or female, or for women who enhance their facial features through methods like eyebrow shaping, eyelash extensions, and lip augmentation? They exceed the natural beauty created by Allah and may justify their actions by claiming that society accepts such practices. After achieving their desires, they may repent, but only after the fact. How can they sincerely repent if they wish to, and is there any detail regarding this? [AR_ID:557]

Answer 1

Peace be upon you.

First: It is important to note that not all the examples mentioned are prohibited. For instance, regarding eyebrow shaping, scholars have ruled that it is permissible in itself, although it may be forbidden under other circumstances, such as involving prohibited looking or touching, or being considered a form of adornment. The determination of this falls on the individual, and further details can be found in religious question applications or other resources.

However, it seems from your question that you are not seeking to know the ruling on the specific examples mentioned, but rather the ruling on those who violate Islamic law.

Second: Regarding the violation of Islamic law, there is no disagreement among scholars that sincere repentance erases sins, provided that the individual truly regrets their actions and intends not to return to them. The fact that society may be engaging in actions contrary to Islamic law is not an excuse, neither rationally nor religiously. In our social lives, we do not accept someone stealing our property or infringing upon us simply because society is doing so. The same applies to religious rulings. Moreover, if a person believes that what they see in Islam is correct, abandoning it under the pretext of societal norms will not exempt them from punishment in the Hereafter.

Additionally, if your intention is that some individuals deliberately violate Islamic law while fully aware, saying after committing the sin that they will repent, such actions may first lead to a lack of divine assistance in repentance. Who among us can guarantee their survival after committing a sin to repent, or who can ensure they will be successful in their repentance? Repeated sins can lead to the heart becoming darkened.