Is Reading a Supplication Equivalent to Listening to It?

Question

The question addresses whether reading a supplication carries the same reward as listening to it, and similarly for the Quran. The response discusses the merits of both actions based on Islamic teachings.

Answer 1

Peace be upon you.

Regarding supplication, there are indications that it is recommended to make supplications in all circumstances. However, we have not found evidence that specifically recommends listening to supplications. It could be argued that listening is recommended based on some general principles, but not specifically as a unique act of worship.

As for the Holy Quran, there is evidence supporting both reading and listening to it as recommended actions. Therefore, both are commendable, but determining which one carries more reward requires a thorough examination of all the evidence, as some sources suggest that both actions yield the same reward, while others indicate that reading has a greater reward. Here are some references:

1. The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him and his family) said: "Allah protects the listener of the Quran from worldly afflictions, and the reader from the afflictions of the Hereafter."

2. "By the One in Whose hand is the soul of Muhammad, the listener of a verse from the Book of Allah—while believing—has a greater reward than giving away a mountain of gold in charity."

"And for the reader of a verse from the Book of Allah—believing—there is a reward greater than what is beneath the Throne down to the lowest depths."

3. The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him and his family) stated: "The reader of the Quran and the listener share the same reward."

4. Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (peace be upon him) said: "Whoever listens to a reciter reading it—meaning Surah Al-Fatiha—will receive a reward equal to one-third of that of the reciter. So let one of you take advantage of this good opportunity, for it is a bounty that should not be wasted, lest it leaves regret in your hearts."

May you be successful in all good deeds.