Date
Date
اللغة:
Font Size:
Night | Day mode
brightness_autoPeace be upon you and God's mercy and blessings.
Upon reviewing the books, we find that they have discussed the man in question.
Your inquiry requires historical study and genealogical investigations, which are not typically addressed through religious questions. Therefore, it is essential to review what has been mentioned in the texts and reflect on them to gain assurance in their outcomes.
However, what we can do is present to you the words of two scholars from our tradition, seeking your understanding, as the excuse is accepted among honorable people:
(First Statement)
One who mentioned him is the religious authority, Sayyid Al-Khoei, may God have mercy on him, who said in his dictionary:
"Muhammad ibn Ubayd Allah ibn Al-Husayn: Al-A'sghar. Sayyid Al-Muhanna mentioned in 'Umdat Al-Talib' (the fifth section regarding the descendants of Al-Husayn Al-A'sghar from Imam Zain Al-Abidin, peace be upon him): 'As for Muhammad Al-Hawani ibn Ubayd Allah Al-A'raj, he is attributed to Al-Hawaniyah, a village in Medina. His mother was a concubine, and he was the executor of his father's will. He was generous and noble, and he died at the age of thirty-two.'"
He mentioned earlier that Ubayd Allah Al-A'raj is the son of Al-Husayn Al-A'sghar ibn Ali Zain Al-Abidin, peace be upon him.
I say: According to what Sayyid Al-Muhanna mentioned, the name of Muhammad's father is Ubayd Allah. However, it appears from Al-Najashi's account in the biography of Ali ibn Ibrahim ibn Muhammad ibn Al-Husayn that his father is referred to as Abdullah. The Sheikh also mentioned in his 'Rijal' regarding the companions of Al-Sadiq, peace be upon him, Abdullah ibn Al-Husayn ibn Ali ibn Al-Husayn ibn Ali ibn Abi Talib, peace be upon him, without mentioning Ubayd Allah ibn Al-Husayn. It has also been noted by the scholars of Sayyid Al-Tafreshi, Al-Mirza, and Mullah Al-Qahbai that Ubayd Allah ibn Al-Husayn ibn Ali ibn Al-Husayn ibn Ali ibn Abi Talib, peace be upon them, is among the companions of Al-Sadiq, peace be upon him. And God knows best.
Dictionary of Hadith Scholars - Sayyid Al-Khoei - Vol. 17 - Page 289
Another scholar who discussed him is Allama Sayyid Mohsen Amin in his valuable book 'A'yan Al-Shi'a', addressing the issue mentioned in the second part of your question.
He said: "Abu Ali Ubayd Allah Al-A'raj, son of Al-Husayn Al-A'sghar, son of Ali Zain Al-Abidin, son of Al-Husayn, son of Ali ibn Abi Talib, peace be upon him." In 'Umdat Al-Talib', he died in the village of Nadi in Iran or Dhi Aman, which is a place in Khorasan, during his father's lifetime at the age of thirty-seven, according to Abu Nasr Al-Bukhari. Abu Al-Hasan Al-Amiri said he was forty-six years old and was known as Abu Ali. His mother was Umm Khalid, and according to Abu Nasr Al-Bukhari, she was Khalida, daughter of Hamza ibn Mus'ab ibn Al-Zubayr ibn Al-Awwam. He had a physical defect in one of his legs, which is why he was called Al-A'raj. He is known as Ubayd Allah the First because he had two sons, each named Ubayd Allah. He visited Abu Al-Abbas Al-Saffah, who granted him a property in Al-Mada'in, which yielded eighty thousand dinars annually. Ubayd Allah had refrained from pledging allegiance to the Nafs Al-Zakiyya, Muhammad ibn Abdullah Al-Mahd, who swore that if he saw him, he would kill him. When Ubayd Allah was brought before him, Muhammad closed his eyes for fear of breaking his oath. Ubayd Allah went to Abu Muslim in Khorasan, who granted him many provisions, and the people of Khorasan honored him. This displeased Abu Muslim, and Suleiman ibn Kathir Al-Khuza'i said to Ubayd Allah, 'We made a mistake regarding you and placed the pledge in the wrong place, so let us pledge allegiance to you and call for your support.' Ubayd Allah thought this was a trick from Abu Muslim, so he informed him of this, which made Abu Muslim uncomfortable with him and he distanced himself, saying, 'O Ubayd Allah, Nishapur cannot bear you,' and he killed Suleiman ibn Kathir Al-Khuza'i, who had previously held a grudge against him.
A'yan Al-Shi'a - Sayyid Mohsen Amin - Vol. 8 - Page 136
And peace and blessings be upon our master Muhammad and his pure family.