home Main feed Recent help_outline Ask Share settings Settings
language
×
العربية English German
search
×

Search

home Main feed Recent help_outline Ask content_copy Copy Question settings Settings

Date

 Date


اللغة:


Font Size:


Night | Day mode

brightness_auto
menu search
brightness_auto
🤖 AI Notice: This translation was generated by AI and is currently awaiting human verification.
more_vert
A question regarding the authenticity of a hadith attributed to Imam Ali (peace be upon him) found in Bihar al-Anwar, Volume 59, Page 272, which mentions a specific recipe involving saffron, costus, and honey.
thumb_up_off_alt 0 like thumb_down_off_alt 0 dislike

1 Answer

more_vert

Peace be upon you and God's mercy and blessings.

The information you mentioned is indeed found in Bihar al-Anwar, and it is noted that it is feared that the person may be a sorcerer due to the strong preservation of the recipe.

It is important to mention that in the heritage of the Shia Imami regarding medical matters, some aspects are well-established by specialists, while others require a thorough examination of their chains of narration and a reflective approach.

Some scholars, like the author of Bihar, may believe that the remedies and supplications mentioned do not require strong chains of narration.

Conversely, there is another perspective that argues for a specialized study, which necessitates providing scientific premises and examining jurisprudential branches and foundational issues that cannot be elaborated upon here.

(A final note):

The religious authority, Sayyid Sistani, may God preserve him, pointed out a significant scientific benefit when discussing some treatments mentioned in the narrations, such as the leftover drink of a believer, stating:

(As for the believer, it seems recommended to consume their leftover drink; however, another title may apply that contradicts this recommendation.)

This may refer to the issue of contagion and the health problems that may arise from it.

He mentioned a limitation indicating that if another title applies, it may negate the recommendation or even the permissibility of consuming it if there is a significant risk of harm.

It is assumed that the result is that drinking from the leftover of a believer is recommended unless the situation is one where medical advice strongly advises against it for one reason or another.

May you remain under God's care and protection and continue to receive His guidance.


Source:

(1)Bihar al-Anwar - Allama Majlisi - Volume 59 - Page 273

(2) Sayyid Sistani's website

thumb_up_off_alt 0 like thumb_down_off_alt 0 dislike

No related questions found

All rights reserved - Quoting is permitted with proper attribution
2024
...