home Main feed Recent help_outline Ask Share settings Settings
language
×
العربية English German
search
×

Search

home Main feed Recent help_outline Ask content_copy Copy Question settings Settings

Date

 Date


اللغة:


Font Size:


Night | Day mode

brightness_auto
menu search
brightness_auto
🤖 AI Notice: This translation was generated by AI and is currently awaiting human verification.
more_vert
This Q&A addresses the issue of excessive doubt (kathir al-shakk) in religious practices, particularly in the context of prayer and whether one should pay attention to their doubts or disregard them.
thumb_up_off_alt 0 like thumb_down_off_alt 0 dislike

1 Answer

more_vert

Peace be upon you.

According to Grand Ayatollah Khamenei and Grand Ayatollah Sistani:

The determination of what constitutes excessive doubt is based on common understanding. If a person regularly doubts about their prayers—specifically, if they doubt in one of three prayers—they are considered to be among those with excessive doubt.

On the other hand, a person who experiences severe doubt to the point of obsession (waswasa) has a heightened sensitivity, particularly regarding issues of impurity. Both categories are similar in that they should not pay attention to their doubts. This condition is alleviated when the individual no longer doubts in the manner described.

Note:

According to Grand Ayatollah Khamenei:

A person with excessive doubt should not pay attention to their doubts, except in one case: if they doubt whether they have performed a prayer and the time for that prayer is still available, they must perform the prayer in question, unless they are obsessive, in which case they should disregard their doubt.

If a person with excessive doubt or an obsessive person becomes certain that their action is invalid, and their certainty is not contrary to common understanding, they should not assume their action is valid.

According to Grand Ayatollah Sistani:

The ruling for an obsessive person regarding performing a prayer is that they should not pay attention to their doubts and should proceed with the prayer, even if it is within the time frame. The same applies to those with excessive doubt.

If a person with excessive doubt or an obsessive person becomes certain that their action is invalid, and their certainty is not contrary to common understanding, they should not assume their action is valid.

May you be successful in all good.


Source:

Grand Ayatollah Khamenei: Fiqh of the Guardian - Rulings on Excessive Doubt

Grand Ayatollah Sistani: Official Website + Minhaj al-Salihin - Vol. 1 - Parts of Ablution - M 74 + Doubt in Prayer + Excessive Doubt

thumb_up_off_alt 0 like thumb_down_off_alt 0 dislike

No related questions found

All rights reserved - Quoting is permitted with proper attribution
2024
...