home Main feed Recent help_outline Ask Share settings Settings
language
×
العربية English German
search
×

Search

home Main feed Recent help_outline Ask content_copy Copy Question settings Settings

Date

 Date


اللغة:


Font Size:


Night | Day mode

brightness_auto
menu search
brightness_auto
🤖 AI Notice: This translation was generated by AI and is currently awaiting human verification.
more_vert
A person asks about the validity of their actions while following different religious authorities and the implications of doubts during prayer.
thumb_up_off_alt 0 like thumb_down_off_alt 0 dislike

1 Answer

more_vert

Peace be upon you.

Ayatollah Khamenei (may God protect him):

1 - The actions of a layperson without following a religious authority or following an invalid authority are considered valid if:

- They are in accordance with precaution.

- They conform to the fatwa of the jurist they were previously following.

- They conform to the fatwa of the jurist they are currently following.

2 - It is sufficient to place the palms on the ground; there is no need to place the fingers.

3 - If one has certainty or suspicion, they should act according to their certainty or suspicion, and the prayer is valid.

Source: Educational Message, Ijtihad (1), Actions Without Following + Message on Prayer and Fasting, Prayer, Obligations of Prayer, Prostration + Doubts in Prayer, Doubt in Rakat Count


Ayatollah Sistani (may God protect him):

1 - If one knows how to perform their actions, they should refer to the jurist who meets the conditions. If the action conforms to their fatwa, it is valid, and it may also be considered valid in some cases of non-compliance, such as if their following of the first jurist was due to ignorance and they neglected something that does not invalidate the prayer, like non-essential parts of the prayer, or if their following was due to negligence and they neglected something that does not invalidate the prayer except intentionally, like loudness or quietness in prayer.

However, if they do not know how to perform their previous actions, they can assume their validity except in certain cases, such as if they believe a part or condition is invalid and suspect they performed it inadvertently. Even in this case, if the non-compliance does not lead to any consequence other than the obligation to repeat the prayer, it is not deemed obligatory.

2 - There is no need to place the fingers during prostration.

3 - If one has certainty or suspicion, they should act according to their certainty or suspicion, and the prayer is valid.

Source: Minhaj al-Salihin, Vol. 1, Ijtihad, M 11 + Prostration + Doubt in the Number of Rakat in Obligatory Prayer, M 865

May you be successful in all good.

thumb_up_off_alt 0 like thumb_down_off_alt 0 dislike

No related questions found

All rights reserved - Quoting is permitted with proper attribution
2024
...