home Main feed Recent help_outline Ask Share settings Settings
language
×
العربية English German
search
×

Search

home Main feed Recent help_outline Ask content_copy Copy Question settings Settings

Date

 Date


اللغة:


Font Size:


Night | Day mode

brightness_auto
menu search
brightness_auto
🤖 AI Notice: This translation was generated by AI and is currently awaiting human verification.
more_vert
The question pertains to the authenticity of the narration regarding the night prayers mentioned in Bihar al-Anwar, specifically a narration about praying two units on Saturday night.
thumb_up_off_alt 0 like thumb_down_off_alt 0 dislike

1 Answer

more_vert

Peace be upon you and God's mercy and blessings.

Some scholars practice many recommended acts as explicitly stated in various texts.

They do not focus on the chain of narration and follow this path based on two principles:

The first principle is known as the principle of leniency regarding the evidence of recommended acts.

They justify acting upon these narrations based on what has been reported from the pure Ahl al-Bayt, such as the narration from Safwan from Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) who said: "Whoever hears something about the reward for a good deed and acts upon it will receive the reward, even if the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him and his family) did not say it."

There are also other hadiths that are beneficial in this context, such as the narration from Hisham ibn Salim from Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) who said: "Whoever hears something about the reward for a deed and performs it will receive the reward, even if it is not exactly as he heard it."

The second principle is known as the principle of hope for desirability. Therefore, many of them have stated in their practical letters:

If it is known that a certain action is not forbidden and it is not known whether it is obligatory, permissible, recommended, or disliked, it is permissible to perform it in the hope that it is desirable and with the expectation of reward.

Refer to Sayyid Sistani's website, for example.

Finally, it is worth noting that scholars have differed regarding the implications of these narrations. Some deny their indication of anything beyond guiding what reason dictates regarding the reward for compliance, asserting that they do not contain any additional legislative authority. Others claim that they indicate a significant foundational issue, providing a major benefit, which is the authority of weak narrations if they include the indication of a Sunnah or a recommended act. Some argue that they indicate the desirability of actions that lead to reward in a secondary capacity, thus implying a secondary legal ruling.

These are specialized discussions that are explored in the religious seminary.

May you remain under God's care, protection, and continuous guidance.

thumb_up_off_alt 0 like thumb_down_off_alt 0 dislike

No related questions found

All rights reserved - Quoting is permitted with proper attribution
2024
...